How to Tell If Your Alternator is Failing (And What to Do About It)

Devin Kelley • April 8, 2025

Your car’s alternator is the unsung hero of your vehicle’s electrical system. It keeps your battery charged, powers your headlights, radio, and electronics, and ensures everything under the hood runs smoothly. But when it starts to fail, it can lead to frustrating issues—or worse, leave you stranded with a dead battery.

At All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia, MO, we’ve helped countless drivers catch alternator problems early. Here’s how to tell if your alternator is failing—and what steps to take before it turns into a costly breakdown.


What Does an Alternator Do?

The alternator generates electrical power and charges your car’s battery while the engine is running. Without it, your battery would drain quickly, and your vehicle wouldn’t be able to function.

It’s a key part of your car’s electrical system, and when it starts to go bad, you’ll notice signs in several areas.


6 Common Signs Your Alternator Might Be Failing

1. Dimming or Flickering Lights

If your headlights or dashboard lights are dim or flickering, especially when idling, it could mean your alternator isn’t generating enough power.


2. Dead Battery (Again and Again)

A weak alternator can’t charge your battery properly. If you’ve recently replaced your battery but it keeps dying, the alternator could be the real issue.


3. Electrical Issues

Malfunctions in your radio, power windows, heated seats, or dashboard instruments can be a clue. These components depend on steady power from the alternator.


4. Strange Noises Under the Hood

A failing alternator may produce a grinding or whining sound due to a worn bearing or damaged internal components.


5. Battery Warning Light or Dashboard Alerts

Your dashboard’s battery icon might light up when the alternator is underperforming. This warning is often misunderstood—it doesn’t always mean the battery is bad!


6. Engine Stalling or Trouble Starting

Since the alternator powers key engine components, a failing one can cause your car to stall or struggle to start, even if the battery seems fine.


How to Confirm It’s the Alternator (and Not the Battery)

Battery and alternator issues often get confused, but there are a few key ways to tell them apart:

Symptom Battery Problem? Alternator Problem?

Car won’t start after sitting overnight                             ✓                                                                        ✖

Car dies while driving                                                              ✖                                                                         ✓

Dim lights at low speeds                                                        ✖                                                                         ✓

Needs frequent jump-starts                                               ✓                                                                         ✓ (if alternator isn’t charging battery)


Pro Tip: A quick diagnostic test at All-Star can confirm whether it’s your alternator, battery, or both.


What to Do If You Think Your Alternator Is Failing

If you’re experiencing any of the above symptoms, don’t wait. Driving with a failing alternator can leave you stranded and cause further damage to your battery and electrical system.


Step 1: Schedule a Charging System Diagnostic

Our team at All-Star Automotive Repair can run a complete electrical system test to identify whether the alternator is the culprit.


Step 2: Replace the Alternator (if needed)

If the alternator is worn out or damaged, replacing it will restore reliable power to your vehicle. We’ll walk you through your options and get you back on the road quickly.


Step 3: Check the Battery & Belt

Sometimes, alternator issues are tied to a bad serpentine belt or a weak battery. We’ll inspect everything and make sure your car’s electrical system is in top shape.


Don’t Get Stuck With a Dead Battery — Get It Checked Today

If you’re noticing dim lights, starting trouble, or dashboard warnings, it could be your alternator. Catching the issue early can save you time, money, and the headache of being stranded.

All-Star Automotive in Columbia, MO offers fast, accurate alternator diagnostics and repair. Let our experienced team keep your car’s power flowing strong.


Schedule your charging system check today!


Ignoring your check engine light can lead to costly repairs.
By Devin Kelley April 4, 2025
Ignoring your check engine light can lead to costly repairs, reduced fuel efficiency, and unexpected breakdowns. Learn why early diagnostics can save you money and keep your car running smoothly. Visit All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia for a quick and reliable check engine light diagnostic.
Get your car ready for spring with this essential post-winter maintenance guide.
By Devin Kelley April 4, 2025
Get your car ready for spring with this essential post-winter maintenance guide. Learn how to check your tires, battery, fluids, brakes, and more. Schedule your spring car check-up at All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia for a smooth and safe ride all season long.
 Learn how to extend the life of your car with tips on tire care, oil changes, and more.
By Devin Kelley March 27, 2025
Dealing with Missouri's hot summers and icy winters? Learn how to extend the life of your car with tips on tire care, oil changes, and more. Keep your vehicle running smoothly with expert advice from All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia, MO.
What are Fuel System Services and Why Do You Need Them?
By Devin Kelley March 27, 2025
Wondering what a fuel system service is and why you need it? Learn how cleaning your fuel injectors, throttle body, and combustion chambers can improve fuel efficiency, boost performance, and prevent costly repairs. Visit All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia, MO, to keep your car running smoothly.
By Devin Kelley March 6, 2025
Want to make your tires last longer? Learn how to check tire tread, the importance of regular rotations, and when to replace your tires. Keep your ride safe and efficient with expert tips from All-Star Automotive.
Heading home or taking a road trip from Mizzou? Get your car road-trip ready!
By Devin Kelley March 6, 2025
Heading home or taking a road trip from Mizzou? Get your car road-trip ready with this essential guide! From checking fluids and tires to packing an emergency kit, these tips will keep you safe on the road. Visit All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia, MO, for a pre-trip inspection!
By Devin Kelley February 28, 2025
Wondering what a standard car inspection includes? From brakes and fluids to tires and battery health, find out what mechanics check to keep your car safe and reliable. Book your inspection today at All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia!
Is your car overheating? Learn the 6 most common causes why your car might be overheating.
By Devin Kelley February 27, 2025
Is your car overheating? Learn the 6 most common causes—like low coolant, a faulty thermostat, or a failing radiator—and how to fix them. Stay safe on the road with expert advice from All-Star Automotive in Columbia!
Regular differential fluid changes are key to keeping your vehicle running smoothly.
By Devin Kelley February 20, 2025
Regular differential fluid changes are key to keeping your vehicle running smoothly and preventing costly repairs. Learn why fresh fluid is essential for lubrication, performance, and heat regulation—plus when to schedule a change. Keep your car in top shape with expert maintenance from All-Star!
By Devin Kelley February 19, 2025
Don't let winter's final stretch drain your car battery! Learn essential tips to keep your battery healthy in February and avoid unexpected breakdowns. Visit All-Star for a battery check today!
More Posts