Why Ignoring Your Check Engine Light Could Be Costing You More Money

Devin Kelley • April 4, 2025

Your check engine light is one of your car’s most important warning systems, yet many drivers ignore it, assuming the issue isn’t urgent. While it may not seem like an immediate problem, delaying a diagnosis can lead to more expensive repairs down the road.

At All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia, MO, we’ve seen firsthand how small issues turn into big repair bills when left unchecked. Here’s why ignoring your check engine light could be costing you more money—and what you should do about it.


What Does the Check Engine Light Mean?

Your car’s check engine light is part of the Onboard Diagnostics System (OBD-II). It detects issues with your engine, emissions system, or other critical components.

Solid Check Engine Light – Usually signals a minor issue like a loose gas cap or a failing sensor.
Flashing Check Engine Light
– Indicates a serious problem like engine misfires or overheating, which could cause permanent damage.

Ignoring these warnings can lead to more costly breakdowns, reduced fuel efficiency, and even engine failure.


5 Ways Ignoring Your Check Engine Light Can Cost You More Money

1. Small Problems Get Worse (and More Expensive) Over Time

What starts as a minor sensor issue can quickly lead to larger, more expensive repairs if left unaddressed.

Example:

  • A bad oxygen sensor may not seem like a big deal, but over time, it can lead to poor fuel economy and damage to your catalytic converter—one of the most expensive parts to replace.
  • A misfiring engine can ruin spark plugs, damage pistons, and overheat, leading to complete engine failure.

What a quick diagnostic check could have fixed for $100 might turn into a $2,000+ repair bill.


2. Reduced Fuel Efficiency (Wasting Your Money at the Pump)

A common reason for a check engine light is a faulty oxygen sensor or mass airflow sensor, which affects how much fuel your car burns.

Ignoring this can:

  • Cause your engine to run rich, burning excess fuel.
  • Decrease your miles per gallon (MPG) and force you to fill up more often.

Fixing a faulty sensor early can save you hundreds in wasted fuel.


3. Damage to the Catalytic Converter ($1,000+ Repair Cost)

Your catalytic converter helps reduce harmful emissions, but if it gets clogged or fails, you’ll face an expensive repair bill.

Common causes of catalytic converter failure:

  • Ignoring a misfiring engine
  • A bad oxygen sensor causing poor fuel mixture
  • Continuing to drive with a check engine light on

Replacing a catalytic converter can cost $1,000 or more, making it one of the most expensive repairs you can avoid with early maintenance.


4. You Could Fail an Emissions Test (or Get Fined)

If your check engine light is on, your car may not pass an emissions test, which is required in some areas.

  • Many states automatically fail vehicles with a lit check engine light.
  • A failing emissions system can lead to higher registration fees or fines.

Even if emissions tests aren’t required in Missouri, a bad emissions system can reduce engine efficiency and increase fuel costs.


5. Unexpected Breakdowns = Towing & Emergency Repairs

A flashing check engine light signals a serious issue that could leave you stranded on the side of the road.

  • Emergency towing services and last-minute repairs can be significantly more expensive than preventative maintenance.
  • A sudden breakdown might mean waiting days for repairs, especially if parts aren’t readily available.

A simple diagnostic test could prevent an unexpected $500+ towing and emergency repair bill.


What to Do When Your Check Engine Light Comes On

  1. Check your gas cap – A loose or faulty gas cap can trigger the check engine light. Tighten it and see if the light turns off after a few drives.
  2. Take note of how your car is driving – Are you experiencing rough idling, strange noises, or reduced power? These signs indicate a more serious issue.
  3. Get a diagnostic test ASAP – A professional scan will pinpoint the exact issue, preventing costly damage.

At All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia, MO, we offer quick and affordable check engine light diagnostics to help you avoid major repairs.


Don’t Ignore Your Check Engine Light – Get It Checked Today!

A check engine light doesn’t always mean a major problem, but waiting too long to address it can cost you big.

At All-Star Automotive Repair, our certified technicians can quickly diagnose and repair the issue, keeping your car running smoothly and saving you money in the long run.

Schedule your check engine light diagnostic today!


By Sher Se September 10, 2025
Fall is the perfect time to prepare your car for Missouri's unpredictable winter weather. Learn why September car maintenance matters and trust All-Star Automotive in Columbia, MO for expert service backed by 5-year,50,000-mile warranty.
August 13, 2025
As the back-to-school season kicks off, most families are focused on new clothes, school supplies, and updated routines. But one thing many forget? Your car needs to be school-ready, too. Whether you’re driving your kids to school or a college student heading back to campus, your vehicle plays a big role in keeping your schedule on track. Your Back-to-School Vehicle Prep Checklist Here’s a simple, essential back-to-school car checklist to make sure your vehicle is ready for the busy school year ahead. 1. Check Your Tires Start the year with tires that are safe and road-ready. Check tread depth and look for uneven wear Ensure tire pressure matches your manufacturer’s recommendation Don’t forget the spare tire—it sh ould be inflated and in good shape Worn-out or overinflated tires can be a safety risk, especially with the morning and afternoon school traffic. 2. Test Your Battery If your battery is more than 3 years old, it’s a good idea to have it tested. The last thing you want is a car that won’t start on a busy school morning. Signs of battery trouble: Slow engine crank Dim lights Corrosion around the battery terminals 3. Inspect All Lights Back-to-school season means shorter days are ahead. Make sure your headlights (high and low beams), brake lights, turn signals, and hazard lights are all working properly so you can see and be seen—especially in the early morning or late evening hours. 4. A/C & Heat Check Late summer can still bring high temps, and fall mornings in Missouri can get chilly. Make sure your air conditioning and heating systems are functioning properly to keep everyone comfortable on the way to school. 5. Review Your Brakes Stop-and-go school zone traffic is tough on your brakes. Listen for: Squeaking, grinding, or vibrations Longer stopping distances A soft or spongy brake pedal If you notice any of these signs, come see us at All-Star Automotive for a brake inspection. 6. Schedule an Oil Change & Maintenance Check If you’re due for an oil change, it’s a great time to knock it out before school starts. Pair it with a full multi-point inspection to catch any hidden issues and make sure your vehicle is ready for the routine ahead. Back-to-School Car Prep in Columbia, MO At All-Star Automotive, we help families and students in Columbia stay safe and ready for the road, especially during busy seasons like back-to-school. Taking a little time now to prepare your vehicle can save you from unexpected breakdowns and stressful mornings during the school year. From tire checks to brake inspections, a well-maintained car helps keep your family safe, on time, and worry-free. Le t All-Star Automotive in Columbia, MO be your trusted partner in back-to-school car care—schedule your appointment today and start the year off right.
By Sher Se July 9, 2025
When the summer heat hits Columbia, Missouri, there’s nothing worse than a car A/C that won’t blow cold air. At All Star Automotive, we’ve already seen a surge of drivers coming in with A/C problems—and many waited longer than they should have. If your vehicle’s air conditioning isn’t keeping you cool, now is the time to get it professionally inspected.  In this post, we’ll break down the most common reasons your car A/C might be failing and why trusting a certified auto shop is the best way to fix car AC fast and avoid bigger problems down the road.
Don’t buy a used car without a pre-purchase inspection.
By Devin Kelley April 30, 2025
Don’t buy a used car without a pre-purchase inspection. Discover how a quick check from All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia, MO, can reveal hidden issues, save you money, and help you make a confident, informed decision.
Noticing dim lights, stalling, or a dead battery? It could be your alternator.
By Devin Kelley April 8, 2025
Noticing dim lights, stalling, or a dead battery? It could be your alternator. Learn the warning signs of alternator failure and what to do next. Visit All-Star Automotive for expert diagnostics and fast, reliable service.
Get your car ready for spring with this essential post-winter maintenance guide.
By Devin Kelley April 4, 2025
Get your car ready for spring with this essential post-winter maintenance guide. Learn how to check your tires, battery, fluids, brakes, and more. Schedule your spring car check-up at All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia for a smooth and safe ride all season long.
 Learn how to extend the life of your car with tips on tire care, oil changes, and more.
By Devin Kelley March 27, 2025
Dealing with Missouri's hot summers and icy winters? Learn how to extend the life of your car with tips on tire care, oil changes, and more. Keep your vehicle running smoothly with expert advice from All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia, MO.
What are Fuel System Services and Why Do You Need Them?
By Devin Kelley March 27, 2025
Wondering what a fuel system service is and why you need it? Learn how cleaning your fuel injectors, throttle body, and combustion chambers can improve fuel efficiency, boost performance, and prevent costly repairs. Visit All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia, MO, to keep your car running smoothly.
By Devin Kelley March 6, 2025
Want to make your tires last longer? Learn how to check tire tread, the importance of regular rotations, and when to replace your tires. Keep your ride safe and efficient with expert tips from All-Star Automotive.
Heading home or taking a road trip from Mizzou? Get your car road-trip ready!
By Devin Kelley March 6, 2025
Heading home or taking a road trip from Mizzou? Get your car road-trip ready with this essential guide! From checking fluids and tires to packing an emergency kit, these tips will keep you safe on the road. Visit All-Star Automotive Repair in Columbia, MO, for a pre-trip inspection!